Press "Enter" to skip to content

Philomena Cunk returns with a hilariously misguided take on cinema history

Diane Morgan’s fictional television presenter is back on Netflix with a six-part series exploring the history of film. Despite her deliberately clueless approach, Cunk on Cinema manages to offer viewers an unexpectedly entertaining introduction to the world of cinema.

Few television presenters have been as spectacularly incompetent at their jobs as Philomena Cunk. Played by British comedian Diane Morgan, the fictional host has built a career presenting herself as an authority on subjects ranging from Shakespeare to the Mona Lisa, despite displaying a remarkable inability to understand even the basics.

Cunk first appeared on Weekly Wipe, a news and review programme created by Charlie Brooker, the mind behind Black Mirror. Her uninformed observations quickly became a favourite among viewers, eventually leading to a series of television specials and limited series, including Cunk on Britain, Cunk on Earth and Cunk on Life.

Recognisable in her blue shirt and blazer, Cunk looks like a conventional television documentary presenter. Her delivery, however, deliberately undermines that impression. Morgan’s natural accent, originating from the area around Manchester, contrasts with the polished received pronunciation traditionally associated with British broadcasting.

This combination allows her to play an impressively convincing fool when interviewing real-life experts, often leaving them struggling to maintain their composure as she poses increasingly absurd questions. One memorable example involves her asking whether King Arthur was known for having frequent sexual encounters.

The comedy also targets the conventions of traditional television documentaries. In one scene, Cunk stands among ancient stone ruins and declares that she is walking through the remains of the world’s first city, only to admit that the actual site is in Iraq, far away and considerably more dangerous.

The joke raises a broader question about documentary storytelling: does simply standing at the location of a historical event really give someone any deeper understanding of what happened there?

Her latest project, Cunk on Cinema, takes this approach into the history of film. The six-part series arrives on Netflix on Sunday, with Morgan interviewing a range of industry figures, including director Michael Bay, Die Hard screenwriter Steven E. de Souza, Project Hail Mary composer Daniel Pemberton and several prominent British film critics.

Her journey spans the Lumière brothers’ early cinematograph experiments through to the emergence of generative artificial intelligence. Surprisingly, however, this latest instalment offers something more than a parody of television documentaries: it also manages to provide a reasonably informative introduction to cinema history.

Although Cunk appears convinced that Hollywood’s most famous Western actor was called Wayne George, the series follows much the same chronological path as a conventional introduction to film studies. Ignore the soundtrack and the increasingly bewildered expressions of her interviewees, and viewers could almost mistake it for a straightforward account of cinema’s first century.

There is also an amusing irony in the fact that a programme featuring a presenter who worries about understanding 2001: A Space Odyssey without having watched the first 2,000 films may introduce many viewers to films that rarely feature on Netflix. The streaming platform’s own understanding of cinema history, after all, has often appeared to stop somewhere around the 1980s.

The interviews, meanwhile, are where the series encounters its biggest challenge. Much of Cunk’s comedy depends on her subjects believing that she is genuinely uninformed, allowing Morgan’s character to catch them off guard with her bizarre observations.

Film critics, however, were unlikely to be surprised by the format. Given the attention surrounding the announcement of the series, its participants probably knew exactly what they were signing up for. While they generally maintain straight faces, the spontaneous bewilderment that makes Cunk’s earlier encounters so entertaining is less evident.

Director Michael Bay and screenwriter Steven E. de Souza appear to be among the few genuinely caught off guard. Bay corrects Cunk when she asks why directors use a particular word beginning with the letter C at the end of every take, hinting that she has confused it with something rather less appropriate than “cut”. Eventually, he seems so bewildered by the conversation that he struggles to continue.

“These are strange questions,” he observes.

De Souza appears even less willing to play along. He refuses to humour Cunk when she shows him an artificial intelligence-generated video of Buster Keaton, which she has created on her iPhone. For Cunk, the clip provides definitive evidence that the legendary American actor spoke with a Cornish accent.

At just under 90 minutes in total, with each of the six episodes running for approximately 15 minutes, Cunk on Cinema is roughly the length of a light romantic comedy. Yet it manages to cover a surprisingly broad range of subjects. Just when viewers might assume that a particular milestone in film history has been overlooked, it tends to appear a few minutes later.

Ultimately, the series succeeds both as comedy and as an accessible introduction to cinema history. Its deliberately misguided approach does not prevent it from delivering useful information, even if the facts occasionally emerge almost by accident.

At one point, Cunk refers to Russian filmmaker Sergei Eisenstein’s celebrated masterpiece Battleship Potemkin as “Batshit Pumpkin”, despite standing beneath a cinema marquee displaying the film’s actual title.

At least, in this case, she gets the film clip right.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply