Press "Enter" to skip to content

French food is the worst in the world, argues columnist

From overpriced Michelin-starred restaurants to uninspiring regional dishes, France’s culinary reputation is struggling to keep up with reality.

Some things are so shocking that they can only be said between close friends. And since Britain and France have enjoyed a close relationship – an entente cordiale – since 1904, it is time to tell our neighbours across the Channel something uncomfortable: French food is the worst in the world.

Such a bold claim requires evidence. Consider one of the defining symbols of ambitious French cuisine: the menu dégustation. Over the years, I have learned to be wary whenever I see the words “tasting menu” on a restaurant menu, particularly in provincial France. The reason is simple: it often signals several exhausting hours of elaborate culinary performance, as a mediocre chef attempts to do far too much with perfectly decent ingredients.

What follows is an endless succession of tiny portions, foams, quenelles and elaborate preparations that seem designed more to impress than to satisfy. By the time the meal is over, the diner is left with little more than a photograph of the menu and a severe case of indigestion.

The French countryside also offers another major flaw: repetition. Anyone who has travelled through regions such as Périgord, Ariège or the Jura will recognise the experience. On the first day, a local speciality such as foie gras, an unusual potato dish or preserved duck might seem delightful. But after encountering the same dish for the seventeenth time in eighteen days, even the most enthusiastic visitor begins to crave a curry – any curry, even one made with the very same regional ingredients. The problem is that finding one within a 300-kilometre radius is practically impossible.

There should be a German compound word, perhaps dating back to the Occupation, to describe this quintessential French holiday experience: the desperate longing for absolutely anything other than the local speciality.

Michelin stars offer little protection against such disappointments. After numerous miserable experiences in French Michelin-starred restaurants, I have come to regard them as potential warning signs of pretension, unnecessary culinary theatrics and exorbitant bills. The more stars on display, the higher the price seems to climb.

One of the most memorable British restaurant reviews of the past decade was Jay Rayner’s scathing assessment of Le Cinq in Paris. His three-star dining experience cost €600 in 2017. The review remains remarkable not only for its writing but also for how accurately it captured the excesses of fine dining.

At this point, French readers might reasonably object that the problem lies not with their cuisine but with the expensive restaurants being visited. Surely, they would argue, the answer is to seek out authentic local brasseries, where traditional French cooking is served through the familiar three-course menu du jour.

Perhaps that was once true, but it is no longer the case. Provincial French bistros have become so disappointing that the country has even introduced legislation aimed at improving food quality, apparently without much success. Frozen boeuf bourguignon is still produced in factories in the Île-de-France region, transported to Normandy bistros in the morning and reheated in microwaves at lunchtime. It is then served to diners who supposedly cannot tell the difference – particularly Dutch tourists. Meanwhile, locals either stay home and eat pizza or head to McDonald’s.

What about the new generation of chefs supposedly transforming French cuisine from within? Such figures may feature prominently in more optimistic media coverage, but the reality, according to the writer, is considerably less inspiring. Many of these culinary innovators either do not exist in meaningful numbers or simply fail to deliver.

The latest example is the increasingly elaborate French salad. During a recent visit to the French Basque Country, the writer encountered a combination of ham, melon, bread topped with goat’s cheese and tomato. So far, so reasonable. But the dish also included lettuce, onion, unpeeled slices of hard carrot, quinoa-like grains, sunflower seeds, peppers and another hard cheese. The finishing touch was a sticky, sweet dressing made with honey, oil and mustard.

Presented in an unnecessarily deep bowl, the creation was supposedly a delicious speciality. In reality, it was an incoherent mixture of flavours and textures that made the meal almost impossible to enjoy.

Why has French food lost its appeal? One explanation is that the rest of the world has caught up. French cuisine once occupied an unrivalled position, but today equally good, if not considerably better, food can be found in numerous other countries.

Another problem is the weight of France’s own culinary tradition. Growing up in a country celebrated for its food can create the assumption that cooking ability is somehow inherited. But being French does not automatically make someone a good cook, just as being Italian does not guarantee an ability to sing opera or being British does not make someone a professional footballer. The result, the writer argues, is a culture that produces too many self-confident but mediocre cooks.

The same tradition also discourages genuine experimentation. When chefs do attempt to break away from established conventions, the results can be disastrous, as the complicated salad illustrates.

France has long excelled at preserving its heritage through regulations, codes and traditions. This approach has helped protect historic town centres, but it is less effective when applied to a living language or a cuisine that needs to evolve. The writer draws a comparison with the Académie Française, which has become a symbol of the country’s determination to regulate and preserve its language.

The decision to have French cuisine recognised by UNESCO is presented as another example of this tendency. Rather than encouraging culinary creativity, the writer fears that official recognition could reinforce an increasingly rigid approach to food. France, often a magical country, is becoming a museum nation, with a museum language and, increasingly, museum food served in museum cafés.

Does this mean French food is objectively the worst in the world in terms of taste? Not quite. The writer admits that having eaten in Cuba and Germany provides enough evidence to rule out such an absolute conclusion. The real problem, however, is the country’s persistent insistence that its cuisine remains uniquely exceptional. That reputation no longer reflects reality, making French food perhaps the most disappointing cuisine in the world.

There is, fortunately, one exception. The French have yet to ruin the classic breakfast: a flaky croissant served with good jam and a proper café au lait. It remains as delicious as ever.

The secret to eating well in France today, the writer concludes, may simply be to have breakfast three times a day.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply