The rising cost of housing and a shrinking supply of available apartments have made buying property in New York City a longer-term investment. Buyers purchasing a median-priced home for $900,000 now need nearly 15 years to break even compared with renting, two years longer than in 2025.
A new report by real estate platform StreetEasy found that limited housing inventory is pushing up both rents and sale prices across the city. In October, 21 per cent of homes sold above their asking price, compared with 18.9 per cent a year earlier. Properties spent a median of just 48 days on the market.
The rental market is under similar pressure. Available rental listings fell by 15.2 per cent over the past year, while Manhattan’s median asking rent rose by 8.6 per cent. Citywide median rents reached a record $4,120 a month this spring.
Some neighbourhoods are cheaper to buy than rent
Despite the overall trend, buying can still make financial sense in certain neighbourhoods where rents are particularly high relative to property prices.
In Brooklyn Heights, the median sale price stood at $870,000 in October, while the median asking rent was $5,150 a month. According to the report, buyers in the neighbourhood can reach the break-even point in 6.8 years.
Gramercy Park offers a similar picture. With a median sale price of $962,000 and monthly rent of $5,500, the estimated break-even period is 7.2 years.
In Queens neighbourhoods such as Rego Park and Oakland Gardens, as well as Riverdale in the Bronx, the period falls to just 3.9 years. Median property prices in these areas are around $400,000, while monthly rents average $3,275.
A market shaped by high rents and limited supply
In most New York neighbourhoods, buying a home makes financial sense only for those planning to stay for at least a decade. Buyers need time for property values to appreciate enough to offset closing costs and brokerage fees.
The city’s housing market also differs from much of the United States. Nearly three-quarters of New Yorkers rent their homes, and the market ranges from basic basement apartments to luxury penthouses.
New York is also unusual in the number of residents willing to pay exceptionally high rents, with some luxury apartments commanding as much as $30,000 a month. This wide range of rental options makes the decision between buying and renting particularly complex.







Be First to Comment